For 14 years, I lived and breathed the Protestant faith. I loved Jesus, I read my Bible, I prayed with sincerity, and I sought to live a life that honored God. I am deeply grateful for the foundation that was laid for me there. And yet, even as I loved God, there was an ache in me, an emptiness that I couldn’t name. Questions lingered in my heart that no one seemed able to answer, and a quiet voice kept calling me deeper.
That voice eventually led me home to the Catholic Church.
This is not a rejection of my Protestant brothers and sisters. It is, rather, a testimony of the treasures I have found in the Church Christ Himself founded. I want to share some of the truths that drew me in, truths that many Protestants either reject or misunderstand, and what I believe the consequences of that unbelief are.
Authority and Apostolic Succession
In Protestantism, the foundation is sola Scriptura-the Bible alone. Everyone is free to interpret Scripture as they feel led, and pastors teach according to their understanding. That sounds freeing, but what it creates is fragmentation. Thousands of denominations all claim the Spirit as their guide, yet they contradict one another.
In Catholicism, Christ didn’t leave us to figure things out on our own. He gave His authority to the apostles, and through them, to their successors-the bishops-anchored by Peter and his successors, the popes. The Magisterium guards Scripture and Tradition together, so truth is not tossed about on the waves of opinion.
The consequence of rejecting this authority? Disunity. Confusion. Division. The splintering of Christ’s body into countless pieces.
The Eucharist: The True Presence of Christ
Jesus said plainly, “This is My Body… This is My Blood.” In John 6, He declared, “Unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink His blood, you have no life in you.”
In most Protestant churches, communion is symbolic-a mere reminder. But in Catholic teaching, the Eucharist is not a symbol. It is Jesus Himself-Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity-hidden under the appearance of bread and wine. The early Church Fathers believed this. The saints lived and died for this truth.
The consequence of rejecting this reality? Some Protestants love Jesus sincerely, but they miss the intimacy of literally receiving Him into their bodies, the very Bread of Life that sustains the soul.
Mary and the Communion of Saints
As a Protestant, I was taught to “go straight to Jesus” and to avoid what was called “Mary worship.” But Catholic teaching is not about worship-it’s about family. In baptism, we are born into the family of God, and that family includes those already in heaven. Mary, as the Mother of Jesus, is our mother too, and the saints intercede for us like older siblings praying for their younger ones.
The consequence of rejecting this truth? A Christian is left to fight the battle of faith more alone, without the maternal help of Mary or the intercession of the saints who already see God face to face.
Confession and the Forgiveness of Sins
I used to confess silently in prayer, hoping God forgave me, but never certain. In Catholicism, Christ gave His apostles the authority to forgive sins in His name: “Whose sins you forgive are forgiven them” (John 20:23). In the Sacrament of Reconciliation, I don’t just hope-I hear the words of absolution spoken aloud. My sins are gone, covered by the Blood of Christ.
The consequence of rejecting this sacrament? A life lived in either constant guilt or presumption, without the grace of sacramental assurance.
The Sacraments: Grace Made Tangible
Protestantism often reduces baptism and communion to symbols, with little sense of God acting through them. But in Catholicism, the sacraments are real channels of grace. God uses water, bread, wine, oil, and human hands to pour His life into ours. He meets us in the physical because He made us body and soul.
The consequence of rejecting sacramental grace? Faith risks becoming only intellectual or emotional, missing the incarnational reality of a God who still touches His people through matter.
The Unity of the Church
Jesus prayed in John 17, “That they may all be one.” The Catholic Church, despite her human flaws, remains one, holy, catholic, and apostolic-unbroken in teaching and sacramental life for 2,000 years.
The consequence of rejecting this unity? Endless division and a diminished witness to the world, which looks on and sees not one Church, but a thousand competing voices.
The Consequences of Unbelief
These differences are not small. They shape everything. To miss the Eucharist is to miss Christ’s very Body. To reject apostolic authority is to embrace disunity. To ignore the saints is to walk without heavenly companions. To deny sacramental grace is to live with less strength for the journey.
I don’t say this with pride but with sorrow-for I lived without these treasures for so long. And I share it now with love, because I long for others to discover what I have found.
Coming Home
The moment I knelt at my first Catholic Mass, I wept. Here was Jesus, not symbolically, not distantly, but really and truly before me. Here was Mary, my mother. Here was the Church, ancient and unbroken. Here was home.
My life has not grown easier since becoming Catholic, but it has grown deeper, steadier, and fuller of grace. The sacraments sustain me. The saints surround me. And Christ, truly present in the Eucharist, feeds me.
An Invitation
If you are Protestant reading this, I honor the faith you hold. But I also invite you to ask, What if there is more? What if the treasures of the Catholic Church are the fullness of what Jesus intended for His people?
Come and see. Pray, study, and be open. The Church is not a museum of rituals but the living Body of Christ. And she has been waiting for you all along.
From my Grace Filled Lemons heart to yours,
Laura
Grace Filled Lemons 
Leave a comment